Field notes · 農業全書を読む · Part 1

Is organic matcha better? We went to the source.

What organic matcha really means, what the evidence says about taste, residues and metals, and how Japan fed its finest tea in 1697, read page by page from the original book.

HHiroto Y.Tea farmer and researcher, TeafyPublished 16 November 202614 min read

Checked against primary sources9 passages read in the 1697 original16 sources, all listedTranslated by a tea farmer and researcher
Two printed pages of the tea chapter of Nōgyō Zensho in vertical Japanese text, pages 222 and 223 of the 1894 printing held by Japan's National Diet Library

The short answer

Organic matcha is matcha from tea grown and processed to a certified organic standard; for Japanese matcha that is JAS 1605, which bans synthetic fertilisers and pesticides and needs three years of conversion before a tea garden's first organic harvest. Is it better? For pesticide residues, yes: studies find far fewer. For heavy metals, the label tells you nothing. For taste and colour, shading and good feeding matter more than the word organic. Japan grew tea without synthetic chemicals for centuries, and a 1697 farming book shows Uji fed its best gardens heavily, but old methods are not a certificate. Look for a recognised certification mark, and buy from a seller who can back the claim.

In this guide
  1. What is organic matcha?
  2. Is organic matcha better?
  3. Does matcha need to be organic?
  4. How Japan grew tea before chemicals
  5. Was traditional matcha organic?
  6. Why shade grown matcha is so green
  7. What does JAS organic mean?
  8. How much Japanese tea is organic?
  9. How to tell if matcha is really organic
  10. Buying organic matcha in Australia
  11. Questions people ask
  12. How we researched this
  13. Sources

Ask anyone selling matcha whether it is organic and you will hear a yes, a no, or a story about tradition. The stories are the problem. "Grown the traditional way" sounds like organic, costs nothing to say, and proves nothing.

So this guide does two things. It answers the questions people actually ask about organic matcha, with the research behind each answer. And it goes back to the tradition itself: the tea chapter of Japan's most important farming book, published in 1697, read in the original Japanese and translated line by line. As far as we can find, this is the first time these passages have been translated into English.

Key takeaways

  1. Organic matcha means certified: for Japanese tea, JAS 1605 and a certifier registered with Japan's Ministry of Agriculture.
  2. The clearest proven benefit is lower pesticide residues. Lower, not always zero.
  3. Organic says nothing about heavy metals. Only lab results do.
  4. Colour and sweetness come mostly from shade and nitrogen, not from the organic label.
  5. In 1697, Uji fed its best tea harder than anyone: night soil, sardines and oil cake, "as much as your means allow". Before chemicals did not mean low input, and it did not mean organic.

What is organic matcha?

Organic matcha is matcha made from tea leaves grown and processed under a certified organic standard, without chemically synthesised fertilisers or pesticides, by a farm and maker inspected by an approved certifier. For matcha from Japan, the standard is JAS 1605, and the proof is a recognised organic certification mark on the pack.

The important word is certified. Organic is not a feeling about how a tea was grown; it is a chain of checks that ends with a mark on the pack.

Step 1The standardJAS 1605 sets the rules: inputs, conversion, separation, records.
Step 2The certifierA body registered with Japan's Ministry inspects the operator at least once a year.
Step 3The operatorKeeps records for every field and grades each lot against the standard.
Step 4The packA certification mark shows the lot passed. This is the part you see.

How an organic claim on Japanese matcha is built. Source: JAS 1605 and the Ministry's labelling notice.

Is organic matcha better?

Better at what? The question splits four ways, and the research gives a different answer to each. Here is how strong the evidence is for an organic advantage on every one.

Organic matcha, scored by the evidence

Filled dots show how strongly the research supports an advantage for organic.

Pesticide residuesToxicology Reports, 2021
Clear advantage

Of 103 Japanese retail teas, neonicotinoids turned up in both groups, but far less often and at far lower levels in organic.

Theanine and tasteFood Chemistry Advances, 2023
Mixed

Organic tea is often higher in catechins and lower in theanine, linked to slower nitrogen. A well fed organic garden can close the gap.

Colour and sweetnessJ. Agric. Food Chem., 2010
Shade decides

Shading raises chlorophyll and theanine and lowers bitter catechins, organic or not.

Heavy metalsHow organic rules work
Not covered

Metals come from soil, water and air. Organic rules control what a farmer adds, not what is already there.

Single studies in particular places; your matcha may differ. Full references in the sources.

So the honest answer is: organic matcha is better if residues are your concern, and it is neither better nor worse on its own for colour, taste or metals. For metals, ask for lab results. We publish ours in our heavy metal testing guide.

Does matcha need to be organic?

Not by law, and not for safety in every case. Japan and Australia both set limits on pesticide residues for all tea, organic or not. But there is one good reason organic matters more for matcha than for most teas. With leaf tea you brew the leaves and throw them away. With matcha you drink the whole leaf, ground to powder. Whatever is in the leaf ends up in the cup, so residues matter more. That is the case for organic matcha in one sentence, and it is a fair one.

How Japan grew tea before chemicals

To see what traditional tea growing really looked like, we went to 農業全書 (Nōgyō Zensho), the Complete Book of Agriculture, compiled by 宮崎安貞 (Miyazaki Yasusada) and published in Kyoto in 1697, the year he died. Its eleven volumes became the standard farming manual of Edo Japan. Volume seven covers four useful trees, and tea comes first.

We read it in the 1894 printing published by 学友館 (Gakuyūkan), held by Japan's National Diet Library and free to view online. The tea chapter runs from page 221 to page 228. Tap a highlighted column on page 223 below to read it.

Read page 223 yourself

Vertical Japanese reads top to bottom, right to left. Tap a numbered column.

Page 223 of the 1894 printing of Nōgyō Zensho, vertical Japanese text, with three columns marked where the book describes how Uji manured its tea

Column 1 · Page 223

さてこやしを入る事は三月摘仕舞て

As for manuring: once the third month picking is done…

Tap columns 2 and 3 to keep reading.

Image: National Diet Library Digital Collections, 農業全書 (学友館, 1894), page 223. Translation: Hiroto Y.

Here is every line that matters from the chapter, in order. The Japanese is as printed in 1894, with the old character forms; only the vertical repeat mark is written out. Switch languages or read side by side.

The tea chapter, line by line

農業全書 巻之七 茶 第一. Page numbers from the 1894 printing.

Page 221 · Where to plant

茶園に作る地の事樹下北陰に宜しとて茶は日當を好まず

On the ground for a tea garden: it is said to suit the shade beneath trees, on the north side, for tea does not like the full sun.

Page 221 · Manure and flavour

糞しを用ゆるが風味よき物なり

Using manure is what gives the tea a good flavour.

Pages 221 to 222 · Uji's soil

山城三園の土地いづれも赤土の石地にて風霜はげしき陰地なり

The ground of the three great gardens of Yamashiro is all red, stony earth, shaded land beaten by fierce wind and frost.

Page 222 · Drainage

茶は少かたさがりたる地に宜し然るゆへに陰地をば好むといへども水濕のもれやすき所によきとしるべし

Tea suits ground with a slight slope. So although it likes shade, know that it does well where the wet drains away easily.

Page 223 · Feeding after picking

さてこやしを入る事は三月摘仕舞てより園中の草を削り根の廻りを深くうち山草はほどろをいか程も多く根の廻りに入れ其後も古葉蜘のゐをはらひのけ人糞鰯油糟にても其求めのある者は力次第おほく入べし

As for manuring: once the third month picking is done, hoe the weeds in the garden and dig deeply around the roots. Pack in as much mountain grass and bracken around the roots as you can. After that, clear away old leaves and spider webs, and put in night soil, sardines or oil cake, whichever you can get, as much as your means allow.

Pages 223 to 224 · Through the winter

冬中も根の廻りをかきのけたびたび糞を入れ乾きたる土をおほひ置べし

Through the winter too, rake the soil back from the roots, put in manure again and again, and cover it with dry soil.

Page 224 · The colouring dressing

又春になりて摘べき三十日ほど前に色付とて糞を少薄くして根の廻りにかくれば廿日ばかりにてはきく物なり かくのごとくなれば芽立心よく出てうるはしく色よくなる物なり 是宇治にて上茶を仕立るにする事なり

Then in spring, about thirty days before picking, pour slightly thinned manure around the roots as a colouring dressing. It takes effect in about twenty days. Done this way, the buds come up well and turn a beautiful colour. This is how Uji raises its top grade tea.

Page 224 · Every other garden

他所の雑園は草を削り下草を多く入れ牛馬糞などをき寒の中一二度も糞を入ればかたのごとくよき茶にはなる物なり

For ordinary gardens elsewhere: hoe the weeds, put in plenty of undergrowth, lay down cattle and horse dung and the like, and manure once or twice in the cold season. The tea turns out good, in the ordinary way.

Page 224 · When picking starts

凡三月の節に入てつみはじむる

Picking generally begins once the third month's seasonal turn arrives.

Translation: Hiroto Y. The months are the old lunar calendar, so the third month falls roughly in April. Where a modern edition reads differently, we quote the 1894 text as printed.

The year of top grade tea, 1697

Put those lines in order and you get a calendar. Feed hard after picking, keep feeding through the cold, give one light dressing before the new shoots. The rhythm is still recognisable on tea farms today.

一月1二月2三月3四月4五月5六月6七月7八月8九月9十月10十一月11十二月12UJI · 1697上茶の一年A year of top grade tea

What happened when

  • Second month: the colouring dressingThinned manure, about 30 days before picking.Page 224
  • Third month: pickingBegins as the third month's seasonal turn arrives.Page 224
  • After picking: feed hardDeep digging, grass and bracken, then night soil, sardines or oil cake.Page 223
  • Winter: again and againRake back the soil, manure repeatedly, cover with dry earth.Pages 223 to 224

Lunar months; the book gives jobs by season, so the bands are approximate. Source: Nōgyō Zensho, 1894 printing.

Notice the word colour, 色. Three hundred years ago Uji's growers were already feeding their gardens for the green of the leaf, and timing it to the picking. Today we know why it works: nitrogen is the raw material for chlorophyll and for theanine, the amino acid behind matcha's sweet, savoury taste. The book had the method long before anyone could measure the result.

More manure, higher grade

A second book from the same year confirms the pattern. 本朝食鑑 (Honchō Shokkan), a food encyclopedia published in 1697, links the grade of Uji's tea directly to how many times its garden was fed with night soil.

Night soil applications by grade of Uji tea

Number of feedings between autumn and spring, as described in Honchō Shokkan (1697).

白 (shiro)The top grade
7 to 8
極詰, 別儀詰Fine grades
4 to 5
極揃, 別儀揃Middle grades
2 to 3
上揃, 煎茶Everyday tea
1

As translated in 島田勇雄 訳注『本朝食鑑 2』(東洋文庫 312), pages 117 to 118. We have not yet read this passage in the original.

Two kinds of garden

Uji's top grade gardens and ordinary gardens, 1697

As described on pages 223 and 224 of Nōgyō Zensho, 1894 printing.

Uji, top grade
VS
Ordinary
Weeds hoed, roots dug deep
After picking
Weeds hoed
Mountain grass and bracken
Mulch
Undergrowth
Night soil, sardines, oil cake
Feed
Cattle and horse dung
Again and again, all winter
How often
Once or twice
Thinned manure, 30 days out
Before picking
Not described
A beautiful colour
Result
Good, in the ordinary way

Sardines and oil cake had to be bought. Historians call these purchased fertilisers 金肥, money manure, and Kyoto Prefecture's heritage research describes Uji's growers buying rapeseed cake and dried sardines and bringing night soil up from the city by river boat. Miyazaki's phrase 力次第, as much as your means allow, says it in three characters. Great tea cost money in 1697 too.

Was traditional matcha organic?

No, and this is the line we hold to. Nothing in the 1697 chapter is a synthetic chemical, because none existed yet. It would be easy to call that organic. We will not, and you should be wary of anyone who does.

Question
Uji, 1697
JAS organic today
Synthetic fertilisers
None existed
Prohibited
Pest control
Not described in the chapter
Only listed, permitted materials
Inputs
Whatever the farmer could get and afford
Only materials on the approved lists
Records
None required
Kept for every field and lot
Neighbouring fields
No rule
Protected from drift and runoff
Inspection
None
A registered certifier, at least yearly
Can you check it?
Only through books like this one
Yes, through the certification behind the mark

Left column from Nōgyō Zensho, pages 221 to 224. Right column from JAS 1605.

Organic today is not a style of farming. It is a set of rules, written down, inspected and enforced, and a mark on the pack that only certified tea may carry. The old book tells us what Uji's best growers fed their tea. It cannot tell us everything they did, what a neighbour used, or whether any of it would pass an inspection. That gap is exactly what a certificate closes.

Why shade grown matcha is so green

Miyazaki writes that tea does not like the full sun. Uji did something about it, earlier than most people realise.

1400sSoil from an old Uji garden shows covered growing by the first half of the 1400s.Soil science journal, 2019
Early 1600sJoão Rodrigues describes reed or straw screens over Uji's gardens.História da Igreja do Japão
1697Nōgyō Zensho and Honchō Shokkan. Reed screens from about 48 days after Setsubun to the 88th night.Honchō Shokkan, as translated
1894The printing of Nōgyō Zensho we read for this guide.National Diet Library
1971Kyoto develops a two tier black cloth system, which largely replaces reed and straw.Kyoto Prefecture
TodayAbout 10% of Uji's covered gardens still use reed and straw.Kyoto Prefecture

Shade in Uji, from soil evidence to today. Full references in the sources.

This is why shading, not certification, is the bigger driver of matcha's colour and sweetness. An organic matcha that was poorly shaded will be duller and more bitter than a well shaded one, whatever the label says.

What does JAS organic mean?

JAS 1605 is Japan's organic standard for crops. For Japanese tea, this is what sits behind the word 有機 (organic) on a pack.

Rule
What it means
Conversion
Tea is a perennial, so a garden needs at least three years of organic management before its first organic harvest.
Inputs
No chemically synthesised fertilisers, pesticides or soil improvers. Only materials on the standard's approved lists.
Separation
Fields protected from drift or runoff of prohibited substances from neighbours.
Records
The certified operator keeps production records and grades each lot before marking it.
Certifier
A body registered with the Ministry, inspecting at least once a year.
The mark
Only certified produce may carry the organic JAS mark. Without it, produce cannot be sold as organic in Japan.

JAS 1605 有機農産物, Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, revised 2024.

How much Japanese tea is organic?

Less than the shelves suggest. Tea is one of the most organic crops in Japan by share, and still most Japanese tea is not organic.

About 1 in 15

The Ministry's figures for the 2023 season put organic JAS tea at about 6.6% of Japan's tea production. Organic vegetables are under half a percent, and rice about a tenth of a percent.

Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, 有機農業をめぐる事情, October 2025.
Organic JAS tea fields by prefecture, hectares

As at 31 March 2025. Japan's total: 1,955 ha, 7.4% of all organic JAS farmland.

Kagoshima
1,009
Shizuoka
344
Miyazaki
250
Mie
67
Kyoto
57
Nara
46
Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, 国内における有機JASほ場の面積 (31 March 2025). Includes fields in conversion.

Look at Kyoto. Uji, the home of matcha, sits in Kyoto Prefecture, and its organic tea area is small. Organic tea is hard to grow anywhere, and hardest in the shaded, heavily fed gardens that make top grade tencha. Researchers in Shizuoka report yields falling by a fifth to two fifths during conversion, with summer weeds and leafhoppers among the hardest problems. That is why genuine organic matcha costs more.

How to tell if matcha is really organic

In Australia, the ACCC says a product does not legally need certification to be called organic, but any business that makes an organic claim must be able to prove it. So the word alone tells you very little. Pick the line that matches your pack.

What does your matcha pack say?

Tap the closest match.

Choose an option to see what it tells you.

Buying organic matcha in Australia

Five checks that separate real organic matcha powder from a good story.

  1. A recognised certification markNot just the word organic. A mark means a certified standard and inspections stand behind it.
  2. Made in Japan, with a regionUji, Kagoshima, Shizuoka. A named region is a traceable one.
  3. Shade and harvestOrganic does not replace shade. Look for first harvest, shade grown tencha for colour and sweetness.
  4. MillingStone milled for drinking straight; other methods are fine for lattes and baking.
  5. Lab resultsThe only answer on heavy metals. Ask for them, or read ours.

Teafy's Ceremonial, Kyoto Uji Ceremonial and Superior Culinary matcha carry organic certification marks on every pack. Our Premium Cafe Blend is a non organic product, and we say so on its page.

Questions people ask

What is organic matcha?
Matcha made from tea leaves grown and processed under a certified organic standard, without chemically synthesised fertilisers or pesticides. For matcha from Japan the standard is JAS 1605, which needs at least three years of organic management before a tea garden's first organic harvest. The proof is a recognised organic certification mark on the pack.
Is organic matcha better than non organic matcha?
For pesticide residues, yes: a survey of 103 Japanese teas found residues far less often and at far lower levels in organic tea, though not always zero. For colour and sweetness, shading matters more than organic status. For heavy metals, organic certification tells you nothing; only lab results do.
What is the difference between organic and non organic matcha?
Organic matcha is grown without synthetic fertilisers or pesticides under a certified standard with yearly inspections, records and a conversion period. Non organic matcha may use approved synthetic inputs within legal residue limits. Both can be excellent or poor; shading, harvest and milling decide most of the quality.
Does matcha need to be organic?
Not by law. Japan and Australia set residue limits for all tea. But because you drink the whole leaf with matcha rather than throwing the leaves away, whatever is in the leaf ends up in the cup, which is the strongest reason to choose organic matcha.
Does organic matcha taste different?
It can. Organic fertilisers release nitrogen slowly, and nitrogen feeds the amino acids that give matcha its sweet, savoury depth, so a poorly fed organic garden can taste thinner. A well fed, well shaded organic garden can taste every bit as good.
Does organic matcha contain lead or heavy metals?
Organic rules control what a farmer adds, not what is already in the soil, water and air, so organic certification is not a heavy metal guarantee. Because matcha is the whole leaf, lab results are the only real answer. Teafy publishes its heavy metal test results.
Is organic matcha the same as ceremonial matcha?
No. Organic describes how the tea was grown and certified. Ceremonial describes a grade for drinking straight, usually first harvest, shade grown and stone milled. A matcha can be both, either or neither.
What does the JAS organic mark mean?
It shows that the produce was grown and made under Japan's organic standard by an operator certified by a body registered with Japan's Ministry of Agriculture. Without the mark, produce cannot be sold as organic in Japan.
Can matcha be called organic in Australia without certification?
The ACCC says organic certification is not legally required for a product supplied in Australia to be described as organic, but any business making an organic claim must be able to prove it. A recognised organic certification is that proof.
Was traditional Japanese matcha organic?
It was grown before synthetic fertilisers and pesticides existed, and the 1697 farming book Nōgyō Zensho describes feeding Uji's best tea with night soil, sardines and oil cake. But organic today is a certified standard with records and inspections, and old books cannot show that a tea met it, so it should not be called organic.
What is Nōgyō Zensho?
農業全書, the Complete Book of Agriculture, compiled by Miyazaki Yasusada and published in Kyoto in 1697. It became the standard farming manual of Edo Japan. Its seventh volume opens with a chapter on tea covering soil, planting, manuring and making tea.

How we researched this

  • Primary source. Every Japanese line on this page was read in the 1894 printing of Nōgyō Zensho held by Japan's National Diet Library, with its page number, so you can open the same page.
  • Translation. By Hiroto Y., tea farmer and researcher. Where the wording differs from modern editions, we quote the 1894 text as printed.
  • Secondary sources. Where we rely on a modern translation or study instead of the original, we say so beside it.
  • Data. Organic areas and shares come straight from the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, dated as published.
  • Not health advice. For questions about your own health or diet, talk to your GP or an accredited dietitian.
  • Updates. We date every change to this page below the sources.

Cite this guide

Hiroto Y. (2026). Is organic matcha better? We went to the source. Teafy. Translation of Nōgyō Zensho (1697), vol. 7, tea chapter, pp. 221 to 224 of the 1894 printing. https://teafy.com.au/blogs/guides/organic-matcha

H

Hiroto Y.

Tea farmer and researcher, Teafy

Hiroto is a third generation Japanese tea farmer and researcher, currently undertaking a PhD in Japanese tea. He writes about the field: seasons, cultivars, shade and everything that happens to a leaf before it becomes tea. This guide is part one of his series on Nōgyō Zensho.

Sources

  1. 宮崎安貞 編録『農業全書』巻之七「四木之類 茶 第一」. First published 元禄10年 (1697). Quoted from the 学友館 printing, 明治27年 (1894), pp. 221 to 224. National Diet Library Digital Collections, info:ndljp/pid/839277. dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/839277
  2. 『日本農書全集 第13巻 農業全書(巻六から巻十、巻十一附録)』農山漁村文化協会, 1978. National Diet Library, info:ndljp/pid/12633780.
  3. 人見必大『本朝食鑑』(1697). 島田勇雄 訳注『本朝食鑑 2』東洋文庫 312, 平凡社, pp. 117 to 121.
  4. João Rodrigues, História da Igreja do Japão (early 1600s), as cited in 宇治市『宇治市歴史的風致維持向上計画』. city.uji.kyoto.jp
  5. 井上弦 ほか (2019). 京都府宇治市の茶園土壌を用いた覆下栽培の発祥時期の推定. 日本土壌肥料学雑誌 90(6). jstage.jst.go.jp
  6. Kyoto Prefecture, 宇治茶の世界文化遺産登録 資料「茶の生産・加工・流通」. pref.kyoto.jp
  7. Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, JAS 1605 有機農産物 (Notification No. 1473, 2022; revised 2024).
  8. Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries and Ministry of Finance, Notification No. 24 (2022) on the form of the organic JAS mark.
  9. Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, 国内における有機JASほ場の面積 (31 March 2025). maff.go.jp
  10. Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, 有機農業をめぐる事情 (updated 21 October 2025).
  11. University of Shizuoka, 茶の有機栽培 (2022). University of Shizuoka
  12. Nimako C, Ikenaka Y et al. (2021). Neonicotinoid residues in commercial Japanese tea leaves produced by organic and conventional farming methods. Toxicology Reports 8: 1657 to 1664. doi.org/10.1016/j.toxrep.2021.09.002
  13. Piyasena K, Hettiarachchi L (2023). Comparison of tea quality parameters of conventionally and organically grown tea. Food Chemistry Advances 3: 100399. doi.org/10.1016/j.focha.2023.100399
  14. Ku KM et al. (2010). Metabolomics analysis reveals the compositional differences of shade grown tea. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 58: 418 to 426. doi.org/10.1021/jf902929h
  15. ACCC, Organic claims. accc.gov.au
  16. Keyword research: Google Ads Keyword Planner and live Google results, Australia, checked 16 November 2026.

First published 16 November 2026. We update this page when the numbers change, and date every change here.

Organic matcha from Teafy